In our continued coverage of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, Ralph welcomes James Zogby, co-founder and president of the Arab American Institute and author of "Palestinians: The Invisible Victims.” Then, no-nukes activist Harvey Wasserman joins to warn us about the dangerous condition of nuclear reactors across the country, including the threat of “embrittlement” at the California reactor in Diablo Canyon.
I'm posting below a link to a web site where people can read a statement about the horrific situation and "sign to support immediate de-escalation and ceasefire in Israel and occupied Palestine." This is sponsored by US Representative to Congress, Rashida Tliab, and I learned about this in an email from Justice Democrats.
Since 1947 uncritical support of Israel without reparations and compensation for lives lost during their warS, for lives lost, businesses stolen or destoyed, homes destroyed or land stolen by settlers or military in OCCUPIED foreign-mostly Jordan, Egypt-- territories; toward indigenous Palestinians has been a ethical, moral failure of the Cold War and onward. Yes, BOTH sides in these conflicts have engaged in terrorism and are at fault; and both should lay down all arms and attend UN sponsored peace talks that give BOTH sides defensible borders and access to trade and work and restoration to more normal lives. The main error was the 1920s oil oligarchs-USA and UK-- NOT adopting Lawrence of Arabia's plan for indigenous homelands for ALL populations in the post WWI Ottoman Empire's Levant lands. The whole world has been held captive to this greed mistake for over a century. The imposition of apartheid by the zionist Israelis proves they have NOT learned the real lessons of the WWII Holocaust. Only if two nations emerge from such peace talks OR a true Federation of Israel and Palestine as ONE nation state with full citizenship and property and voting rights for Arabs will this inhumanity stupidity ever have an end.
by “Hamas” Biden met simultaneously with both Zelensky & Netanyahu.
“It is possible” that this “Suicide Attack” was “Staged” so USA could use Isreal in Ukraine,
Iran, China & Africa .. especially to take over the BRIC Countries.
I say BLACKMAIL was involved so this clandestine confrontation would have an Arab~Face.
I say the Isreali’s need to demand equalization
for the homeland their Roots are in & they took care of for so many generations.
I believe the NATO FORCES wish to poision & bomb this living planet (that has no rites anymore) & use space stations to play shooting games at is from space (such as with their thermal devices & to eliminate all oxygen in closed areas as was done in Torah Bora.
Great show. Zogby is clear-headed, informative, and brave. One observation: I’m not satisfied with his answer to the question of why it took six hours for the Israeli military to respond.
Even if the military were completely “bogged down” in the West Bank, how long could it have taken for it to remove itself to the other side of this tiny country if it wanted to do so? It could not have been uninformed about the situation for that long, and there were also cryptic reports just after 10/7 that Egyptian intelligence told Israeli intelligence, and I believe Netanyahu himself, before 10/7 that something big was about to happen and that those warnings were ignored. The same pattern was present after 9/11: clear warnings ignored, inexplicably slow response time that, in my view, has never been adequately explained.
Zogby could at least have added that this must be investigated before coming to any confident conclusions about the reason(s) for this catastrophic fiasco.
I appreciate Zogby's condemning the attack on Oct 6th and not using the word "but" and I I will respond to James Zogby offer for his book.. Maybe after reading the book it will give me an answer to my question. How to you separate Hamas from the Palestinian people that live in the Gaza Strip?
The topic of this episode is very similar to Mr. Nader’s recent blog post. Most of what was said in the dialog between Mr. Nader and Mr. Zogby, along with what is in the blog post, is correct. That said, the same problem I pointed out last week with the previous RNRH episode is repeated in this week’s RNRH and in Mr. Nader’s blog post.
“Biden did come back with a bill for the American taxpayers – who for decades have been forced to pay for these Israeli wars.
…
That sum of money, to be authorized without any Congressional hearings or Congressional oversight, is greater than the combined annual budgets of the FDA, OSHA, NHTSA and the section of HHS, whose missions are to reduce the loss of hundreds of thousands of preventable American fatalities in the workplace, on the highways, and in the marketplace and the hospitals.”
The first sentence in the above quote is balderdash. There is not a taxpayer bill for funding the Israeli wars. Similarly, there will not be taxpayer bills if funding is expanded for FDA, OSHA, NHTSA, healthcare, or anything else. Tax returns, though completely necessary, are canceled money. They do not fund US federal government spending. This is not how government spending works when government is a currency issuer with a fiat currency and that is what we have with the US federal government.
Of course, there is a very high cost to the American public, and the global population as a whole, for the US’s support of genocide in the Middle East and other US foreign policy misadventures which have been mentioned in previous RNRH episodes. First is the culpability that our government is supporting genocide. Beyond that, there is a tremendous environmental cost to all of these military actions. We are contributing to the global refugee crisis which has only led to the rise of the likes of Trump across the west. Our foreign policy misadventures create significant domestic security risks for the US and for other countries including Israel. Our foreign policy misadventures leads to further cultural backwardness at home and certainly abroad. These are just some of the high humanitarian costs, rather than budgetary costs, of our actions. These are the costs Mr. Nader should have mentioned, not the piffle regarding ‘taxpayer money’.
On a related point, Mr. Wasserman made the connection between the nuclear arms industry and nuclear power. Given what I wrote above, the solution is simple: nationalize the military industry and right-size it to support only national defense. This would eliminate the nuclear arms industry and their need for corporate welfare-fueled expansion, via military misadventures, merely to please Wall Street. Naturally, full employment must also be funded to make this politically viable.
While I really do appreciate Mr. Nader’s efforts to accurately portray what is going on in the Middle East, Mr. Nader’s economic follies here, and elsewhere, severely tarnishes the credibility of Mr. Nader’s arguments. I hope Mr. Nader will put stubbornness aside and will do better in the future so that I can recommend these episodes to others without qualification.
Klassik, this is a bit difficult for me to understand, but could you be referring to ideas, such as those of Stephanie Kelton (I believe), who supports what I think is called Modern Monetary Theory (or such)? I believe this concerns a country's currency when it is a fiat currency. I believe that means a currency issued by the country itself for any expenditures within its own country only. She explains that a fiat currency can be issued in virtually unlimited amounts - but only as long as it is issued for expenditures within its own country, not when it needs to take into account any other currencies, such as debts it needs to repay in other currencies. This position is very attractive to people who want to spend on the public good instead of the current public destruction, since we could fund programs such as full employment for all, Medicare for All, etc. The reason she says "virtually" unlimited spending is not clear to me, but I think inflation could be triggered in certain situations, so there are some constraints on unlimited spending. This is a very complex idea that is hard to grasp, especially for people not familiar economics of any kind, except kitchen table economics in which money runs out at the end of the paycheck, and which some say does not apply to a fiat currency. I think Stephanie Kelton would be an interesting guest on the RNRH. However, to get the whole picture accurately, I would like it to be a conversation with economist Richard Wolff, who might or might not have a different view. He is extremely interesting, very clear, and he might reveal some of the difficulties with Modern Monetary Policy for our consideration. I'd love to hear these economic giants explain it clearly. Ralph Nader may be sharper than you give him credit for. I believe he and the RNRH team would show the critical expertise to help us out here.
Hi Nancy. I'd like to respond to the part of your post which stated this:
"...that means a currency issued by the country itself for any expenditures within its own country only. She explains that a fiat currency can be issued in virtually unlimited amounts - but only as long as it is issued for expenditures within its own country, not when it needs to take into account any other currencies, such as debts it needs to repay in other currencies."
The money spent into existence by a sovereign currency issuer (like the U.S. govt) goes beyond domestic spending. It's the very reason foreign holders of dollar currency exist. If e.g. the government were to buy a million computer chips from China for government use, they would pay in newly-issued dollars. There's an entire discussion to be had about how that occurs, though the money is usually held in the seller's account at the Federal Reserve. Most often these seller's convert this into treasury bonds to earn interest. That is the 'debt' you mentioned and the interest payments are in US dollars, which are issued for that purpose. The U.S. doesn't borrow foreign currency, receives no 'foreign aid' currency and has no 'foreign debts' of that kind. If it owes money to a foreign entity it is paid in dollars. Helped by the fact that it is the world's most desired currency.
The best things to keep in mind are this: that government can 'theoretically' issue as much money as it likes as spending, but the limits are natural: 1) whether or not there are goods/services available for sale (in that currency). 2) Whether taxation is properly functioning at a level to remove and cancel enough previous issue to allow the 'fiscal space' for spending. Which is the primary mechanism for inflation control. Which also includes, if necessary, reducing competing domestic/private spending power in order to create that space for government expenditure.
The problem of government spending in our economies isn't government financial constraints, but ideological and structural policy constraints. Direct spending to the public purpose is deliberately throttled to allow the majority of money issue to flow to private business interests. Initially on an economic view that this would generate wealth to filter into wider society (so-called 'trickle down'), but now a deep-rooted ideological position with no real thought behind it and where corporate interests have a large influence on national/international economic policy in their favour. So it reproduces itself, with governments convinced that the only way to create any economic activity to fulfil the public purpose starts with business interest. This is why we see 'Bidenomics' doing the usual neoliberal things like trying to 'increase private investment' for things which are public services. Yet at the same time funnelling money into their coffers as 'recompense'. What it boils down to is that the money really comes from government. They could spend it directly to buy goods/services, but instead go through the charade of 'business partnerships' and 'encouraging the private sector to invest'. It's a sham.
Nancy, yes, I am referring to Modern Monetary Theory. MMT is not very well understood by progressives, much less the general public, and so there are a lot of myths out there about it. Some of these are perpetuated by conservatives, but some are perpetuated by progressives who have a vague understanding about it. With that in mind, it is best to refer to MMT scholars such as Stephanie Kelton, L. Randall (Randy) Wray, Bill Mitchell, Warren Mosler, Fadhel Kaboub, Pavlina Tcherneva, and a few others. Kelton would make for a great guest on the RNRH. I think Wray would be an excellent guest as he’s testified before the House Budget Committee and seemingly had a big influence on the former chair of the House Budget Committee, John Yarmuth.
The general myth about the economy is that the national budget of a currency issuer, such as the US federal government, is similar to a budget of a currency user such as families, businesses, and local governments. Also, there is a general belief that increased national spending will lead to inflation. This was pushed by Milton Friedman’s many acolytes. However, that has been empirically proven false, but how many people know that? After all, many school macroeconomics textbooks still push this falsehood as being a truth!
I’m glad you mentioned full employment as labor economics is something very commonly ignored by modern progressives. Full employment is a vital part of MMT. Increased spending can lead to inflation, but increased spending can also be a buffer against inflation if policy is appropriate. An example of poor, inflationary policy would be something like a universal basic income which is pushed in certain economically uninformed progressive corners. On the other hand, a policy of a job guarantee is a buffer against inflation and it would probably be more politically viable than a UBI as well. Long story short, this shows why it is important to base policy on sound economic principles.
I know that some progressives have a distaste for economics. They consider it a ‘conservative’ subject. This is simply not true, economics is vitally important in curbing corporatism. Corporate interests do take economics seriously and if progressives do not counter their policies with economically sound policies, things will continue to be skewed towards corporatism. Many of the basic macroeconomic principles are not difficult to learn. I really hope the RNRH will take these matters more seriously because the RNRH is one of the most important progressive programs out there. It will be a real shame, and a waste, if the RNRH continues to use conservative economic language which promotes pro-corporate austerity economics. This is why I push Mr. Nader fairly hard on this subject.
Richard Wolff has some interesting insights and he could also provide some interesting commentary on the RNRH, but I really hope the RNRH staff takes the names I listed earlier, such as Kelton and Wray, seriously as they know how to speak to a general audience such as Wray speaking to Congress, as I mentioned earlier, or Kelton’s bestseller book. Wray, and possibly the others, could also discuss demilitarization within the economic framework already established by John Kenneth Galbraith.
These are good questions, Don. Ferdy offered a good response, but I’ll offer my response as well. I’ll start with the job guarantee. If the federal government wishes to pursue a policy of full employment, rather than the non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment (NAIRU) based paradigm government uses now which is based on Milton Friedman’s ideas of a ‘natural rate of unemployment’, full employment can be achieved by use of a federal job guarantee program. Unemployment people wanting to work will be guaranteed a livable wage doing work through the job guarantee program. Job guarantee jobs are not jobs which should be done by regularly employed people in the private and public sectors, but ones such assisting at non-profits. Not only do the job guarantee jobs help people maintain a livable wage, but they also keep/sharpen skills necessary to transfer back into regular employment in the private or public sectors. As we know, the private sector, and public sectors, tends to prefer to hire people who are already employed over the unemployed, all else being equal.
The job guarantee program provides a price stabilizing buffer stock for labor. When the private sector needs to hire, the price of hiring someone out of the job guarantee is known and stable and it does not lead to inflation-causing swings caused by typical stimulus (corporate welfare) approaches where government transfers money to the private sector and then hopes to create jobs for the unemployed via trickle-down methods. The job guarantee then also acts as an unofficial minimum wage as well as there would be no reason for someone to work a private sector job which pays below the livable wage of the job guarantee program.
As for universal basic income, let me present the example of low-income housing in a private housing paradigm where there is a limited supply of supple low-income housing. This is the reality we live in today in the US. If people are given a UBI, the private sector will just increase the prices based on the public’s increased ability to pay ‘thanks’ to the UBI. The UBI has not increased productivity either, so there are inflationary issues there on the supply side while UBI maintains demand, and nothing has been done to prepare people to transfer into private or public sector employment.
Furthermore, the biggest pushers of UBI are ones who wish to replace traditional means-tested benefits for a UBI. This is an austerity measure as the value of the UBI will not be equivalent to the value of the means-tested benefits for those who need it the most. In addition to the inflationary aspects of UBI, be wary of those who push it as they are probably pushing an austerity agenda and a generally conservative agenda.
UBI is potentially inflationary because it is the issue of money with potentially no productive outcome. It might remain unspent and untaxed. Or it may just be spent in a way that creates no useful outcome. The issue is bigger than just personal spending use. The point tof a JG is multi-faceted: that it takes up unemployment where the private sector cannot/will not and also creates output for the public purpose. Plus offers a living wage to those employed. Who are then taxed as normal (according to income). This is a normal flow of issue and taxation. A UBI isn't doing any of this. It is running along the same principle of: issue money and then rely upon 'private initiative' which is little different than the problem we already have.
“When a Man lies, he murders a part of the World.”
—(Paul Gerhardt, German Hymn Writer.)
“Only the small secrets need to be protected. The big ones are kept secret by public incredulity.”
—Marshall McLuhan, 1911- 1980.
I'm posting below a link to a web site where people can read a statement about the horrific situation and "sign to support immediate de-escalation and ceasefire in Israel and occupied Palestine." This is sponsored by US Representative to Congress, Rashida Tliab, and I learned about this in an email from Justice Democrats.
https://actionnetwork.org/forms/sign-to-support-immediate-de-escalation-and-ceasefire-in-israel-and-occupied-palestine/?source=group-justice-democrats&referrer=group-justice-democrats&redirect=https%3A%2F%2Fsecure.actblue.com%2Fdonate%2Fjdem-20231022%3Frefcode%3Dem20231022
Since 1947 uncritical support of Israel without reparations and compensation for lives lost during their warS, for lives lost, businesses stolen or destoyed, homes destroyed or land stolen by settlers or military in OCCUPIED foreign-mostly Jordan, Egypt-- territories; toward indigenous Palestinians has been a ethical, moral failure of the Cold War and onward. Yes, BOTH sides in these conflicts have engaged in terrorism and are at fault; and both should lay down all arms and attend UN sponsored peace talks that give BOTH sides defensible borders and access to trade and work and restoration to more normal lives. The main error was the 1920s oil oligarchs-USA and UK-- NOT adopting Lawrence of Arabia's plan for indigenous homelands for ALL populations in the post WWI Ottoman Empire's Levant lands. The whole world has been held captive to this greed mistake for over a century. The imposition of apartheid by the zionist Israelis proves they have NOT learned the real lessons of the WWII Holocaust. Only if two nations emerge from such peace talks OR a true Federation of Israel and Palestine as ONE nation state with full citizenship and property and voting rights for Arabs will this inhumanity stupidity ever have an end.
The weekend prior to the “Invasive Attack”
by “Hamas” Biden met simultaneously with both Zelensky & Netanyahu.
“It is possible” that this “Suicide Attack” was “Staged” so USA could use Isreal in Ukraine,
Iran, China & Africa .. especially to take over the BRIC Countries.
I say BLACKMAIL was involved so this clandestine confrontation would have an Arab~Face.
I say the Isreali’s need to demand equalization
for the homeland their Roots are in & they took care of for so many generations.
I believe the NATO FORCES wish to poision & bomb this living planet (that has no rites anymore) & use space stations to play shooting games at is from space (such as with their thermal devices & to eliminate all oxygen in closed areas as was done in Torah Bora.
Great show. Zogby is clear-headed, informative, and brave. One observation: I’m not satisfied with his answer to the question of why it took six hours for the Israeli military to respond.
Even if the military were completely “bogged down” in the West Bank, how long could it have taken for it to remove itself to the other side of this tiny country if it wanted to do so? It could not have been uninformed about the situation for that long, and there were also cryptic reports just after 10/7 that Egyptian intelligence told Israeli intelligence, and I believe Netanyahu himself, before 10/7 that something big was about to happen and that those warnings were ignored. The same pattern was present after 9/11: clear warnings ignored, inexplicably slow response time that, in my view, has never been adequately explained.
Zogby could at least have added that this must be investigated before coming to any confident conclusions about the reason(s) for this catastrophic fiasco.
I appreciate Zogby's condemning the attack on Oct 6th and not using the word "but" and I I will respond to James Zogby offer for his book.. Maybe after reading the book it will give me an answer to my question. How to you separate Hamas from the Palestinian people that live in the Gaza Strip?
Sorry I meant Oct 7th
The topic of this episode is very similar to Mr. Nader’s recent blog post. Most of what was said in the dialog between Mr. Nader and Mr. Zogby, along with what is in the blog post, is correct. That said, the same problem I pointed out last week with the previous RNRH episode is repeated in this week’s RNRH and in Mr. Nader’s blog post.
To make things easier, I’ll quote from Mr. Nader’s blog post (https://nader.org/2023/10/20/biden-returns-empty-handed-except-for-a-huge-bill-for-the-american-taxpayers/):
“Biden did come back with a bill for the American taxpayers – who for decades have been forced to pay for these Israeli wars.
…
That sum of money, to be authorized without any Congressional hearings or Congressional oversight, is greater than the combined annual budgets of the FDA, OSHA, NHTSA and the section of HHS, whose missions are to reduce the loss of hundreds of thousands of preventable American fatalities in the workplace, on the highways, and in the marketplace and the hospitals.”
The first sentence in the above quote is balderdash. There is not a taxpayer bill for funding the Israeli wars. Similarly, there will not be taxpayer bills if funding is expanded for FDA, OSHA, NHTSA, healthcare, or anything else. Tax returns, though completely necessary, are canceled money. They do not fund US federal government spending. This is not how government spending works when government is a currency issuer with a fiat currency and that is what we have with the US federal government.
Of course, there is a very high cost to the American public, and the global population as a whole, for the US’s support of genocide in the Middle East and other US foreign policy misadventures which have been mentioned in previous RNRH episodes. First is the culpability that our government is supporting genocide. Beyond that, there is a tremendous environmental cost to all of these military actions. We are contributing to the global refugee crisis which has only led to the rise of the likes of Trump across the west. Our foreign policy misadventures create significant domestic security risks for the US and for other countries including Israel. Our foreign policy misadventures leads to further cultural backwardness at home and certainly abroad. These are just some of the high humanitarian costs, rather than budgetary costs, of our actions. These are the costs Mr. Nader should have mentioned, not the piffle regarding ‘taxpayer money’.
On a related point, Mr. Wasserman made the connection between the nuclear arms industry and nuclear power. Given what I wrote above, the solution is simple: nationalize the military industry and right-size it to support only national defense. This would eliminate the nuclear arms industry and their need for corporate welfare-fueled expansion, via military misadventures, merely to please Wall Street. Naturally, full employment must also be funded to make this politically viable.
While I really do appreciate Mr. Nader’s efforts to accurately portray what is going on in the Middle East, Mr. Nader’s economic follies here, and elsewhere, severely tarnishes the credibility of Mr. Nader’s arguments. I hope Mr. Nader will put stubbornness aside and will do better in the future so that I can recommend these episodes to others without qualification.
Klassik, this is a bit difficult for me to understand, but could you be referring to ideas, such as those of Stephanie Kelton (I believe), who supports what I think is called Modern Monetary Theory (or such)? I believe this concerns a country's currency when it is a fiat currency. I believe that means a currency issued by the country itself for any expenditures within its own country only. She explains that a fiat currency can be issued in virtually unlimited amounts - but only as long as it is issued for expenditures within its own country, not when it needs to take into account any other currencies, such as debts it needs to repay in other currencies. This position is very attractive to people who want to spend on the public good instead of the current public destruction, since we could fund programs such as full employment for all, Medicare for All, etc. The reason she says "virtually" unlimited spending is not clear to me, but I think inflation could be triggered in certain situations, so there are some constraints on unlimited spending. This is a very complex idea that is hard to grasp, especially for people not familiar economics of any kind, except kitchen table economics in which money runs out at the end of the paycheck, and which some say does not apply to a fiat currency. I think Stephanie Kelton would be an interesting guest on the RNRH. However, to get the whole picture accurately, I would like it to be a conversation with economist Richard Wolff, who might or might not have a different view. He is extremely interesting, very clear, and he might reveal some of the difficulties with Modern Monetary Policy for our consideration. I'd love to hear these economic giants explain it clearly. Ralph Nader may be sharper than you give him credit for. I believe he and the RNRH team would show the critical expertise to help us out here.
Hi Nancy. I'd like to respond to the part of your post which stated this:
"...that means a currency issued by the country itself for any expenditures within its own country only. She explains that a fiat currency can be issued in virtually unlimited amounts - but only as long as it is issued for expenditures within its own country, not when it needs to take into account any other currencies, such as debts it needs to repay in other currencies."
The money spent into existence by a sovereign currency issuer (like the U.S. govt) goes beyond domestic spending. It's the very reason foreign holders of dollar currency exist. If e.g. the government were to buy a million computer chips from China for government use, they would pay in newly-issued dollars. There's an entire discussion to be had about how that occurs, though the money is usually held in the seller's account at the Federal Reserve. Most often these seller's convert this into treasury bonds to earn interest. That is the 'debt' you mentioned and the interest payments are in US dollars, which are issued for that purpose. The U.S. doesn't borrow foreign currency, receives no 'foreign aid' currency and has no 'foreign debts' of that kind. If it owes money to a foreign entity it is paid in dollars. Helped by the fact that it is the world's most desired currency.
The best things to keep in mind are this: that government can 'theoretically' issue as much money as it likes as spending, but the limits are natural: 1) whether or not there are goods/services available for sale (in that currency). 2) Whether taxation is properly functioning at a level to remove and cancel enough previous issue to allow the 'fiscal space' for spending. Which is the primary mechanism for inflation control. Which also includes, if necessary, reducing competing domestic/private spending power in order to create that space for government expenditure.
The problem of government spending in our economies isn't government financial constraints, but ideological and structural policy constraints. Direct spending to the public purpose is deliberately throttled to allow the majority of money issue to flow to private business interests. Initially on an economic view that this would generate wealth to filter into wider society (so-called 'trickle down'), but now a deep-rooted ideological position with no real thought behind it and where corporate interests have a large influence on national/international economic policy in their favour. So it reproduces itself, with governments convinced that the only way to create any economic activity to fulfil the public purpose starts with business interest. This is why we see 'Bidenomics' doing the usual neoliberal things like trying to 'increase private investment' for things which are public services. Yet at the same time funnelling money into their coffers as 'recompense'. What it boils down to is that the money really comes from government. They could spend it directly to buy goods/services, but instead go through the charade of 'business partnerships' and 'encouraging the private sector to invest'. It's a sham.
It's pretty complicated but fascinating.
Nancy, yes, I am referring to Modern Monetary Theory. MMT is not very well understood by progressives, much less the general public, and so there are a lot of myths out there about it. Some of these are perpetuated by conservatives, but some are perpetuated by progressives who have a vague understanding about it. With that in mind, it is best to refer to MMT scholars such as Stephanie Kelton, L. Randall (Randy) Wray, Bill Mitchell, Warren Mosler, Fadhel Kaboub, Pavlina Tcherneva, and a few others. Kelton would make for a great guest on the RNRH. I think Wray would be an excellent guest as he’s testified before the House Budget Committee and seemingly had a big influence on the former chair of the House Budget Committee, John Yarmuth.
The general myth about the economy is that the national budget of a currency issuer, such as the US federal government, is similar to a budget of a currency user such as families, businesses, and local governments. Also, there is a general belief that increased national spending will lead to inflation. This was pushed by Milton Friedman’s many acolytes. However, that has been empirically proven false, but how many people know that? After all, many school macroeconomics textbooks still push this falsehood as being a truth!
I’m glad you mentioned full employment as labor economics is something very commonly ignored by modern progressives. Full employment is a vital part of MMT. Increased spending can lead to inflation, but increased spending can also be a buffer against inflation if policy is appropriate. An example of poor, inflationary policy would be something like a universal basic income which is pushed in certain economically uninformed progressive corners. On the other hand, a policy of a job guarantee is a buffer against inflation and it would probably be more politically viable than a UBI as well. Long story short, this shows why it is important to base policy on sound economic principles.
I know that some progressives have a distaste for economics. They consider it a ‘conservative’ subject. This is simply not true, economics is vitally important in curbing corporatism. Corporate interests do take economics seriously and if progressives do not counter their policies with economically sound policies, things will continue to be skewed towards corporatism. Many of the basic macroeconomic principles are not difficult to learn. I really hope the RNRH will take these matters more seriously because the RNRH is one of the most important progressive programs out there. It will be a real shame, and a waste, if the RNRH continues to use conservative economic language which promotes pro-corporate austerity economics. This is why I push Mr. Nader fairly hard on this subject.
Richard Wolff has some interesting insights and he could also provide some interesting commentary on the RNRH, but I really hope the RNRH staff takes the names I listed earlier, such as Kelton and Wray, seriously as they know how to speak to a general audience such as Wray speaking to Congress, as I mentioned earlier, or Kelton’s bestseller book. Wray, and possibly the others, could also discuss demilitarization within the economic framework already established by John Kenneth Galbraith.
How is a UBI an inflationary policy and what is a policy of a job guarantee and how is it a buffer against inflation?
These are good questions, Don. Ferdy offered a good response, but I’ll offer my response as well. I’ll start with the job guarantee. If the federal government wishes to pursue a policy of full employment, rather than the non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment (NAIRU) based paradigm government uses now which is based on Milton Friedman’s ideas of a ‘natural rate of unemployment’, full employment can be achieved by use of a federal job guarantee program. Unemployment people wanting to work will be guaranteed a livable wage doing work through the job guarantee program. Job guarantee jobs are not jobs which should be done by regularly employed people in the private and public sectors, but ones such assisting at non-profits. Not only do the job guarantee jobs help people maintain a livable wage, but they also keep/sharpen skills necessary to transfer back into regular employment in the private or public sectors. As we know, the private sector, and public sectors, tends to prefer to hire people who are already employed over the unemployed, all else being equal.
The job guarantee program provides a price stabilizing buffer stock for labor. When the private sector needs to hire, the price of hiring someone out of the job guarantee is known and stable and it does not lead to inflation-causing swings caused by typical stimulus (corporate welfare) approaches where government transfers money to the private sector and then hopes to create jobs for the unemployed via trickle-down methods. The job guarantee then also acts as an unofficial minimum wage as well as there would be no reason for someone to work a private sector job which pays below the livable wage of the job guarantee program.
As for universal basic income, let me present the example of low-income housing in a private housing paradigm where there is a limited supply of supple low-income housing. This is the reality we live in today in the US. If people are given a UBI, the private sector will just increase the prices based on the public’s increased ability to pay ‘thanks’ to the UBI. The UBI has not increased productivity either, so there are inflationary issues there on the supply side while UBI maintains demand, and nothing has been done to prepare people to transfer into private or public sector employment.
Furthermore, the biggest pushers of UBI are ones who wish to replace traditional means-tested benefits for a UBI. This is an austerity measure as the value of the UBI will not be equivalent to the value of the means-tested benefits for those who need it the most. In addition to the inflationary aspects of UBI, be wary of those who push it as they are probably pushing an austerity agenda and a generally conservative agenda.
UBI is potentially inflationary because it is the issue of money with potentially no productive outcome. It might remain unspent and untaxed. Or it may just be spent in a way that creates no useful outcome. The issue is bigger than just personal spending use. The point tof a JG is multi-faceted: that it takes up unemployment where the private sector cannot/will not and also creates output for the public purpose. Plus offers a living wage to those employed. Who are then taxed as normal (according to income). This is a normal flow of issue and taxation. A UBI isn't doing any of this. It is running along the same principle of: issue money and then rely upon 'private initiative' which is little different than the problem we already have.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gnAe5fSPFto
Pete Seeger, Dar Williams, David Bernz & Rivertown Kids sing Solartopia
Thank you. It took me back, and I enjoyed hearing it, and I hope it can take us forward.
Writer & Poet Mona Damluji:
When I say Palestine, I bear witness to the atrocities of history.
When I say Palestine, I believe another world is possible.
When I say Palestine, I remember how all the keys worn around their necks,
once fit snugly in the palm of their hands as they arrived Home.
When I say Palestine, I see beautiful people healing tree roots torn from the Land.
When I say Palestine, I know right from wrong.
When I say Palestine, I stand proudly on the shoulders of giants and dig my heel into the eye of the monster.
When I say Palestine, I mean Falastin and not occupied territories.
When I say Palestine, I dream of wide open spaces where Life is thriving.
When I say Palestine, I hear the cries of the grassroots, the unstoppable, the victors of this moral battleground.
You can’t make me say conflict, when I mean occupation.
You can’t make me say clash, when I mean they dropped bombs that flattened a city block.
You can’t make me say both sides. You can’t make me say it’s complicated.
You can’t make me say endless cycle of Violence.
When I say, I see how this ends, I mean Peace.
When I say, I see how this ends, I mean Justice.
When I say, I see how this ends, I mean PALESTINE..